The great Irish broadband joke
Calvin posted this on Jul 26th 2007 at 11:28 under Business, Computing, Internet
I just got off the phone with our local wireless broadband operator, Rapid Broadband, who informed me that there was STILL no covarage in my area. I know of three people less than a mile down the road who avail of and are generally very happy with the service — but I seem to be nestled in a lovely little wireless black-spot; a broadband dead-zone.
Our telephone exchange in Leap, as far as I know, hasn’t been upgraded to deliver ADSL, and anyway at around 6KM I think we’re just outside the cut-off point in terms of distance from the exchange. I was starting to get a bit excited about the prospect of mobile broadband — with offerings from Vodafone, O2 and 3 all jockeying for market share it seemed now might be a good time to avail. But no good.
Here in rural Co. Cork the 3G coverage is woeful. The nice lady in West Cork Mobiles in Clonakilty told me that she could sell me the O2 USB modem — but that where I live the coverage would be sporadic at best, and when I could get access it would be at a much slower rate than that advertised. In her words:
I can’t even get it at home, and I’m selling it! We’re treated as second class citizens down here.
It certainly seems that way when it comes to broadband access. Apparently the only places locally that you can get real broadband speeds from 3G are the town centres of Clonakilty and Skibbereen — both of which also have fixed line ADSL and wireless options available to them. Kind of makes a mockery of the term “mobile broadband”, don’t you think?

…or not, as the case may be!
Looks like I’m stuck with the clunky and expensive 64k ISDN connection for the time being. I can live with it, barely, although it has me pulling my hair out when it comes to transferring large files. I just wish I didn’t have to endure all the adverts pushing the latest and greatest broadband options (complete with the usual “subject to availability, terms and conditions apply” guff). Hearing about the sort of connection speeds other people are enjoying when you know you can’t get them yourself is incredibly frustrating!
Every time I hear a new add on the radio, or read one in the newspaper I get excited, even though I know I shouldn’t. I fire up my web-browser, crank up the old ISDN, type in the web address and wait… and wait… and wait.
Why is it that broadband providers — who by definition are trying to appeal to those still struggling with a slower connection, don’t optimise their sites for access over dialup?
Eventually, when the thing does load up, and I access the coverage map and/or line check, the response invariably amounts to “you live where…“. I swear that sometimes I can hear sniggering in the background — or maybe that’s just the cogs whirring as the ISDN struggles to cope with the graphics.
Broadband availability in this country is a JOKE — and not a very funny one at that, especially when you’re trying to run a home-based business that relies heavily on electronic communication.
I feel like the whole media rich, interactive Web 2.0 experience is passing me by. I’m stuck in the narrowband doldrums while the digital revolution roars on without me. I can’t even use Skype properly, for crying out loud, and you can forget things like YouTube, Google Earth or Second Life. Even downloading software updates is a chore: to get the latest OpenOffice.org update I have to crank up the download before going to bed at night. If I’m really lucky and the line doesn’t drop mid-flight it might — just might — be finished when I go back in the morning.
So Santa, if you’re listening… I know it’s only July, but all I want for Christmas is a broadband connection. Surely that’s not too much to ask….
Technorati Tags: broadband, Ireland, mobile broadband, ADSL, wireless broadband, ISDN












Dave on 02 Aug 2007 at 21:33 #
Calvin, Dave in Reenascreena here.
I’ve had the same problems as you but I’ve signed up with Satellite from MediaSat. http://www.mediasat.ie.
I know it’s not broadband and you need a phone line connection but for the likes of us it’s the only hope. I can report that it is very good and way way faster than ISDN. Connection is E200 yo yos then E29.99 a month for 512k download speed or you can go for 1 meg instead at 39.99 a month and they’re based in Cork.
I’d recommend it.
Ola on 14 Aug 2007 at 14:27 #
Hi Calvin,
Im form same area (Leap)
You should go to http://www.ruralservice.net.
Check it out.
It is satellite connection but there is just 6 month contract and you can have 4MB for 29.80 with no download cap!!!
Regards
Ola
Calvin on 15 Aug 2007 at 10:02 #
Thanks both,
I’ve been trying to hold out for a true two-way broadband solution — but it’s starting to get incredibly frustrating. I might have to take another look at the satellite option. The Rural Services option looks like the best bet.
I can live with slow uploads — but the big question is do you have to have your own existing internet connection for uploads / requests or do they provide you with a dialup service included in the monthly fee? (i.e. will I need to keep my €24.99 a month UTVip subscription going just to cater for the upstream element of the service?)
Will look into it further — but I’m still hoping the mobile mast near us will be upgraded to 3G soon (it is flagged for upgrade in the O2 system, apparently), which should make true two-way mobile broadband a viable option.
We’ll see what happens.
ola on 20 Aug 2007 at 10:27 #
You will need to have your dial up connection to get that service as it’s one way sattelite internet access.
Regards
O.
Calvin on 21 Aug 2007 at 9:31 #
Hi Ola,
I suspected as much. I’ll hold out for another couple of months and see if one of the true two-way broadband options becomes available.
Cheers,
Calvin!
Writing for life » Broadband… but only in the playhouse on 31 Aug 2007 at 16:34 #
[...] week I rang Vodafone and asked about Mobile Broadband coverage in my area (I’d already tried O2’s offering with no [...]
bernie stevenson on 09 Nov 2007 at 20:29 #
I live in Kikenny and have th same trouble. I tried th 3mobile but no coverage in my house, but at least they promptly refunded my money no questions asked. The teles sky of rural net is adifferent hill a beans, I paid 286euro for connection, had nothing but trouble. The installer was back 3 times and have tried to contact via the German website, the kind of response is a demand for monthly payment or they’ll cut off service,they dont understand give me my money back.
Calvin on 20 Nov 2007 at 12:33 #
Hi Bernie,
Sorry to hear you’re having trouble.
Since writing this post I’ve been contacted by our local wireless provider who said they could relay a signal off a business that has the service that’s in line-of-sight of my house. Brilliant.
Installation is going to be double… but hopefully it will be worth it.
Still that was four weeks ago and I’m still chasing them.
Best of luck getting your refund from the satellite crowd. Hang on in there… I’m pretty sure we’ll all get “real” broadband access… eventually.
Cheers,
Calvin!